Flavour Is an Illusion: How Your Brain Creates Taste and Perception

What if I told you that you are being lied to?

No it’s not the government, or Mark Zuckerberg, or IKEA customer services. It is in fact your brain.

That’s right, when it comes to the experience of flavour, you are being hoodwinked by the thing you trust the most – your very own brain. But it has mastered the art of deceit so well that you are probably blissfully unaware.

Let’s explain with a hard truth: flavour, as you know it, doesn’t actually exist in the glass. What’s in the glass is just a collection of molecules. Flavour is in fact a lie – a brilliant, beautiful illusion created entirely by your brain. But don’t worry, this isn’t bad news. In fact, it’s one of the most exciting things about tasting drinks, and it’s what we’re going to uncover today.

The Complex Tapestry of Flavour

First, let’s take a moment to appreciate just how powerful our brains are. When you take a sip of whisky, your tongue detects a handful of basic tastes: sweet, salty, sour, bitter, and umami. That’s it. Not a hint of vanilla, no wisp of smoke, and definitely no ‘Christmas pudding.’

Those details come from your sense of smell. When food or drink is in the mouth, airborne molecules escape from it and up into the nasal cavity where the odour receptors hang out. Your nose detects these volatile aroma compounds, but here’s the thing. It makes us believe that rather than being odours in the nose, they are ‘tastes’ in the mouth.

Your brain stitches together aromas and tastes (plus also mouthfeel) into a tapestry we call flavour. And – here’s the twist – your brain doesn’t just stop there. It layers on memories, emotions, cultural context, and even expectations to create the ‘flavour’ you experience."

The Brain’s Tricks: How Flavour is an Illusion

Have you ever picked up a whisky and thought, ‘This smells just like toasting marshmallows on the bonfire,’ or ‘This is Christmas in a glass’? That’s not the whisky, that’s your brain. It’s connecting the aroma compounds to past experiences, emotions, and even the story the label has told you.

A peaty Islay whisky might evoke the rugged seaside for one person and an industrial bonfire for another. The whisky hasn’t changed. What’s different is how our brains interpret the same molecules.

And here’s a fun thought experiment for you: if a bottle of whisky falls over in the middle of the forest and there’s no one around to smell it, does it have an aroma?

Well, no in fact. Molecules themselves are not flavour. They only become flavour after a convoluted process of our receptors interacting with them, creating nerve signals, and a medley of brain regions interpreting those signals as something coherent. In simple terms, those aroma compounds don’t mean a thing until they meet your nose and your brain decides what to do with the information.

This is why at The Sensory Advantage, we teach people not just how to taste whisky but how to understand what their brain is doing while they taste. And because we each have different genes, different brains, different personalities, and different life experiences, how the brain interprets this information will be unique for each individual.

Therefore, flavour, as you know it, is a lie.

The Brain’s Role in Creating Flavour

Research, such as the work of Small et al. (2005) on orthonasal and retronasal olfaction, demonstrates how the brain activates different regions depending on the source of aroma, further proving that flavour is a constructed experience. You can explore this study here.

When we sniff a dram, the brain processes those aroma inputs differently to if we take a sip – even though it’s the same molecules interacting with the same olfactory receptors. Crazy right? But once we layer in genetic variation, plus other factors such as the balance of enzymes, bacteria, and ph in the mouth, the opportunities to experience that whisky in a different way to others becomes astronomical.

Cultural Influences on Flavour Perception

Flavour isn’t just personal; it’s profoundly cultural. What we find delicious or off-putting is shaped by the foods and drinks we grew up consuming. For example, people who use a lot of tamarind in their cooking have a higher tolerance for bitter and sour tastes.

A fascinating study comparing taste sensitivities between Chinese and Indian populations in Singapore found that Indians had higher recognition thresholds for tastes like sweet, salty, and bitter. You can read more about this research here. In other words, they needed stronger concentrations of these tastes to perceive them.

This could be due to the bold, heavily spiced flavours common in Indian cuisine, which may condition the palate over time. Understanding how culture shapes flavour perception helps to add context to why people experience the same whisky differently. This aligns with broader sensory research, such as studies on genetic and cultural impacts on taste perception, which you can explore here.

For those interested in exploring this further, studies like these reveal just how complex and subjective flavour perception is. They also remind us that no two palates are alike, and that’s something to celebrate.

The Liberating Truth About Flavour

Here’s the liberating truth: because flavour is an illusion created by the brain, there’s no such thing as a “right” or “wrong” tasting note. If someone says their whisky tastes like leather-bound books and you taste burnt toast, neither of you is incorrect. Your brains are simply constructing different versions of the same whisky based on your unique sensory inputs and personal history.

What’s more, your experience of flavour isn’t static. It fluctuates depending on factors like mood, environment, and even what you ate for breakfast. This variability means you could experience the same whisky differently on two separate occasions. Embracing this subjectivity can make whisky tasting more enjoyable and less intimidating.

At The Sensory Advantage, we encourage people to let go of the pressure to “get it right.” Our courses focus on understanding the mechanics of flavour perception, empowering participants to trust their own experiences and describe them with confidence.

The Future of Flavour

Understanding that flavour is an illusion doesn’t just make you a better taster; it transforms the way you think about whisky. At The Sensory Advantage, we design courses that delve into the science of sensory perception, helping enthusiasts and professionals alike unlock the secrets of flavour. From exploring how culture shapes taste to mastering the art of describing aromas, our programmes equip participants with the tools to elevate their whisky experiences.

Whether you’re a curious enthusiast or a seasoned professional, there’s always more to discover. Flavour isn’t just in the glass; it’s in your mind. By understanding how your brain constructs flavour, you can approach whisky with curiosity, creativity, and confidence. Ready to unlock the secret to tasting whisky? Let’s raise a glass to the adventure ahead.

Want to learn more? Discover a world of sensory insights in our newsletter by subscribing here.